McCarthy’s Poise Preseason Debut: Vikings’ Hidden Gems Emerge

In the fast-paced world of NFL preseason, where games often feel like a mix of promise and illusion, episodes like this one on The Real Forno Show stand out. It spotlights J.J. McCarthy’s Vikings preseason debut—a crucial moment for a quarterback whose rookie year ended before it began due to injury. Hosted by expert analyst Tyler Forness and producer Dave Stefano, this Vikings 1st & SKOL production delivers more than just highlights; it offers smart breakdowns of player development, roster battles, and hidden gems like undrafted free agents (UDFAs).

McCarthy’s Long-Awaited Return: A Checkpoint for Growth and Composure

The story starts with McCarthy’s Vikings preseason debut, a moment fans have waited for since his 2024 injury sidelined him entirely. Forness sets the scene early: “No rookie quarterback that’s drafted in the first round has ever missed the entire season because of an injury. It’s the first time it’s ever happened.” This unique backdrop makes his 13 snaps against the Texans more than routine—they were a calculated test.

O’Connell prioritized reps to rebuild McCarthy’s game rhythm, even without stars like Justin Jefferson and Christian Darrisaw. Forness notes the Vikings’ careful approach: “They played it very calculated, very careful. And they played him a series with the ones.” The result? McCarthy led a field-goal drive, showing composure on third-down conversions and a scrambling fourth-down run.

However, it’s the intangibles that shine. Stefano praises his pocket presence: “I was looking for thought process and how he handled himself and his pocket presence was, I thought was brilliant.” Forness adds details from O’Connell’s post-game praise: “I think there’s just a level of composure and poise to how he ran the show that was exactly what I was looking for.”

Minor tweaks emerged in camp reviews, like better ball placement on throws to Jordan Addison and Lucky Jackson. Forness explains: “The Lucky Jackson one was a titch early. If he throws that a quarter of a second later, Lucky Jackson brings that in.” Yet, these are learning steps. The hosts tie this to the Vikings’ mantra: “The process is the progress.” Moving forward, joint practices with the New England Patriots offer more tests, like Jefferson versus Christian Gonzalez. Forness buzzes: “Those are the kind of matchups you want on the field, and I am, I can’t wait for that.”

This segment keeps the story rolling by linking McCarthy’s debut to broader team goals, showing how his poise resolves doubts about his readiness after a lost year.

UDFAs Rise Above: Stealing the Show in Roster Battles

Transitioning to depth players, the episode highlights how UDFAs turned the Texans game into a showcase. Forness dives in: “The Minnesota Vikings had some big risers and fallers throughout their first preseason game.” Why focus here? Because in preseason, backups often play more, revealing who might crack the 53-man roster.

EDGE rusher Gabe Murphy leads the charge. Sidelined much of 2024 by a knee injury, he exploded with 1.5 sacks and five pressures in 30 snaps. Forness breaks it down: “He registered 1.5 sacks and five pressures on the day, and was explosive getting around the offensive tackle.” Despite short arms—a common critique—Murphy’s speed wins out. Forness draws from Von Miller: “Most pass rushers, like about 90% of the wins are because I’m bigger, faster, and stronger than you.”

Bo Richter complements him, shining on special teams and defense. Forness notes: “Murphy and Richter combined for two sacks on the day, and both looked great in attacking the quarterback around the edge.” Richter’s versatility from Air Force days adds value for coordinator Brian Flores.

Inside, DT Elijah Williams—a tryout from Morgan State—impresses with four pressures in 21 snaps. Forness flagged him early: “He was signed after rookie minicamp… He garnered four pressures on 15 pass rush snaps.” O’Connell’s quote underscores the hunger: “Guys like that are hungry… Guys like that are four times more likely to make the 53-man roster.”

Not everyone rose. Veterans like RB Ty Chandler (five yards on five carries) and NT Taki Taimani (limited snaps) dipped. Forness warns: “If he wants to make the team, Chandler is going to need to improve in that area.” These contrasts push the story ahead, illustrating how UDFAs resolve depth concerns by challenging established players.

Quarterback Depth Heats Up: Gamers and Projects

Building on McCarthy, the hosts explore backups, where Sam Howell rebounds from camp woes. Forness calls him a “gamer”: “Howell went 11-13 for 105 yards, and made good decisions across the board.” This eases fan worries about the position.

Aug 9, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Vikings quarterback Max Brosmer (12) passes against the Houston Texans in the fourth quarter at U.S. Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Rempel-Imagn Images

UDFA QB Max Brosmer adds intrigue, throwing a touchdown with sharp anticipation. Stefano observes: “What I saw from him was making his reads first, second, third, fourth, even.” Forness predicts: “If that’s that way for the next two games, Brosmer’s making the team straight up.” Brett Rypien’s struggles (1-4 for six yards) contrast sharply.

This section advances the narrative by showing quarterback stability beyond McCarthy, resolving why the Vikings’ depth could sustain injuries or slumps.

Wide Receiver Rumors and Injuries: No Need to Panic

Wide receiver talk simmers, fueled by potential additions like Adam Thielen. Forness pushes back: “People need to honestly shut up about the fact that the Vikings need wide receiver talent. They don’t.” With T.J. Hockenson and running backs like Aaron Jones, the offense has options.

However, injuries loom—Rondale Moore’s knee issue prompts concern. Forness notes Moore’s Instagram post: “Blessed,” hinting it might not be season-ending. Lucky Jackson rises as WR4: “Jackson being the guy at WR4 is a good sign for him not just making the roster, but also being a contributor.”

Stefano frames trades hypothetically: “If we’re in Win NOW mode… Would that make sense?” Yet, both agree: No panic. This resolves trade buzz by emphasizing internal strength.

Defensive Versatility and Joint Practices: Looking Ahead

Cornerbacks like Mekhi Blackmon get extended reps for experience, not demotion. Forness clarifies: “I think they wanted to play him to just get him reps.” Versatility shines, with Flores favoring multi-positional players.

The defensive line’s depth impresses, countering preseason illusions. Forness states: “If you can’t dominate third teamers, I don’t want you on my team.” Joint practices promise more: “You get way more from joint practices than you do the games.”

Injuries persist league-wide, but the Vikings’ resilience—winning without stars last year—builds hope. Stefano sums: “The injury plague is hot and heavy.”

Listen:

Watch:

A Vikings Team on the Rise

This episode wraps by tying threads together: McCarthy’s poise, UDFA breakthroughs, and depth resolve why this Vikings preseason McCarthy debut game excites. Forness concludes: “I’m excited about where things are trending.” In 2025, Minnesota isn’t rebuilding—they’re refining. SKOL Vikings!

FAN WITH US!!!

Tyler Forness @TheRealForno of Vikings 1st & SKOL @Vikings1stSKOL and A to Z Sports @AtoZSportsNFL, with Dave Stefano @Luft_Krigare producing, this The Real Forno Show @RealFornoShow. Podcasts partnered with the Fans First Sports Network @FansFirstSN and the network’s NFL feed over at Pro Football Insiders @Pro_FB_Insiders. Your ultimate source for NFL insights, breaking news, and expert analysis. From draft prospects to game-day strategies, we’ve got the inside scoop!

Question

Which player from the Vikings’ preseason game against the Texans do you think will have the biggest impact in the regular season, and why?